Seals of the Court of Appeals and Superior Court
District of Columbia Courts
VISIT US | CAREERS

DC Court of Appeals Opinions and MOJs

Opinions

The court publishes opinions in cases that provide both the litigants and the trial court with guidance, create new law, or interpret statutes or concepts. These decisions are published in print and on the DCCA website. They are binding precedent, which means they can be cited as supporting authority in other cases.

MOJs

The court issues a Memorandum Opinion and Judgment (MOJ) in cases where the decision does not create new law, decide an issue of continuing public interest, or interpret a statute or concept that has yet to be reviewed. The decisions are issued by the panel (per curiam), not under the name of an individual judge. They are not published, and except as permitted by Appellate Rule 28(g), they may not be cited as supporting authority in other cases. For that reason, the court only lists online the names and case numbers of MOJs that have been issued. If a party or other interested person believes that a specific MOJ should be published, the party or interested person may file a motion to publish no later than 30 days after the MOJ issues.

Appeal Number Case Date Disposition Judge
16-CF-344 Darryl Malloy v. US Jun 21, 2018
16-BG-1094 In re Claire Ogilvie Jun 21, 2018
18-BG-401 In re Carl Epstein Jun 21, 2018
12-CF-141 Devino Harding v. US Jun 19, 2018 Affirmed Hon. Anthony C. Epstein
16-CF-809 Weldon Allen Byrd v. US Jun 18, 2018 Affirmed Hon. Danya A. Dayson
17-CM-182 Aminata Ndir v. US Jun 18, 2018 Affirmed in part; Reversed in part Hon. Patricia A. Broderick
16-CV-585, 16-CV-795 Theresa Saunders v. Denise Valentine, et al. Jun 18, 2018 Affirmed Hon. Maurice A. Ross
17-FM-834 Navarro Pulley v. Julie Pulley Jun 14, 2018 Affirmed Hon. William W. Nooter
16-FS-632 In re C.A. Jun 14, 2018
16-CO-1053 David J. Brown v. US Jun 14, 2018 Affirmed Hon. John F. McCabe
16-CV-881, 17-CV-23 Unification Church International, et al. v. Family Federation for World Peace & Unification Int'l, et al. Jun 08, 2018 Affirmed Hon. John M. Mott
15-CV-1214 Ludwig & Robinson v. BioTechPharma, et al. Jun 07, 2018
18-BG-98 In re Edward N. Matisik Jun 07, 2018
16-AA-873 Solomon Abebe v. DOES / US Security Assocs., et al. Jun 07, 2018
17-BG-691 In re Douglas A. Kuber Jun 07, 2018
16-CO-567 Larry Dancy v. US Jun 06, 2018 Affirmed. Remanded solely to correct clerical error in sentence Hon. Lynn Leibovitz
17-CM-2 Crystal Monique Foster v. US Jun 05, 2018 Affirmed Hon. Florence Pan
16-AA-421 Melwood Horticultural Training Center, Inc. v. Staci L. Malloy May 31, 2018 Reversed & Remanded Office of Administrative Hearings
16-CT-365 Alisha Townsend v. DC May 31, 2018
16-CV-719 James Black, et al. v. DC May 31, 2018 Affirmed Hon. Thomas J. Motley
16-AA-735 & 16-AA-867 Caryn Hines & Claudia Barber v. DC Commission on Selection & Tenure of Administrative Law Judges of the Office of Administrative Hearings May 31, 2018
16-CO-1248 Alonzo D. Marshall v. US May 30, 2018 Affirmed Hon. Thomas J. Motley
17-CO-262 Jose Gilberto Portillo v. US May 29, 2018 Affirmed Hon. Michael L. Rankin
17-AA-271 Richard A. Walsh, Jr. v. DOES / Verizon Communications, Inc., et al. May 29, 2018 Affirmed Compensation Review Board
16-CM-884 Melvin Johnson v. US May 25, 2018 Affirmed Hon. Wendell P. Gardner, Jr.
17-CV-928 Shonta Roberts v. DC, et al. May 25, 2018 Affirmed Hon. Elizabeth C. Wingo
15-FS-870, 15-FS-871 In re Petition of T.A.H.; D.S.B., C.S. May 25, 2018 Record Remand Hon. Noel T. Johnson, Hon. Robert R. Rigsby
16-AA-1090 Dana Buckner v. DOES / WMATA May 25, 2018 Affirmed Compensation Review Board
15-CF-1349 Musonda Mulenga a/k/a Emmanuel Guzeh v. US May 25, 2018 Affirmed Hon. Jennifer M. Anderson
16-FS-1295 In re J.W., S.T. May 25, 2018 Record Remand Hon. Tara Fentress, Hon. John McCabe
16-AA-369 Blake Nelson v. DC Rental Hous. Comm’n / The Klingle Corp. May 24, 2018
18-BG-324 In re Sharon Styles Anderson May 24, 2018
16-CF-729 Michael Ball v. US May 24, 2018
18-BG-215 In re David Furrer May 24, 2018
17-CO-699 Arthur Vincent Daniels v. US May 23, 2018 Affirmed Hon. Gerald I. Fisher
16-FM-525 Mohamed Ali v. Alaa Ali Abdelghany May 23, 2018 Affirmed Hon. Yvonne Williams
17-CO-261 Leon Boyd v. US May 23, 2018 Record Remand Hon. Lynn Leibovitz
16-FM-1256 Jeffrey Crater v. Martha Oliver May 22, 2018 Affirmed in part, vacated in part, remanded in part Hon. Michael K. O'Keefe
16-CM-373 Shawn A. Dyson v. US  May 22, 2018 Vacated & Remanded Hon. William Jackson
16-CV-1066 George W. Crawford v. First American Title Ins. Co. May 22, 2018 Affirmed (but deny request for fees) Hon. Gregory Jackson
15-AA-254 Ronda L. Nunnally v. DC Police & Firefighters’ Retirement & Relief Bd. May 17, 2018
18-BS-475 In re Alexander Fernandez May 17, 2018
16-AA-587 Peter Minshall et al. v. DC Dept. of Consumer & Regulatory Affairs May 17, 2018
18-BS-472 In re James C. Zinman May 17, 2018
16-CO-953 Paul T. Hiligh v. US May 16, 2018 Affirmed Hon. Judith A. Smith
16-CM-1238 Santos Ruiz v. US May 16, 2018 Affirmed Hon. Danya A. Dayson
17-CO-585 Abraham McDowell v. US May 16, 2018 Affirmed Hon. Maurice A. Ross
16-CV-1067 Lori Nickens v. Medical Faculty Associates, Inc., et al. May 15, 2018 Affirmed Hon. Robert Okun, Hon. Robert R. Rigsby
17-AA-181 Washington Hospital Center, et al. v. DOES / Natividad Montiel May 15, 2018 Affirmed Compensation Review Board
16-PR-1160 In re Estate of Ralph B. Harrington, Jr.; Alice Harrington May 11, 2018 Affirmed Hon. Gerald I. Fisher